Tuesday, February 25, 2014

The Upton Sinclair Statement




Upton Sinclair
It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.

That statement is used a lot these days, particularly in the context of people of privilege not being decent with people who have nothing.

The statement is often quoted as if it were an indubitable truth and yet it is always unsatisfying to me when I hear it. Various people whom I respect highly use it as if it were self-evident, but I don't believe it for a second.

What I see wrong with it is that assumes that the privileged man does not understand something. Perhaps that false assumption is easily accepted because it is flattering to the self to feel smarter than someone else. It allows a feeling of ascendancy or superiority above others, something like that.

I know I've have written and said this many times, but people are far sharper than that, they pick up things far better than even the animals.

They pick up the ascendency-superiority thing immediately, of course, even from a flick of the eyebrow or the incline of the nose or the tone of voice or the corners of the mouth.

But not understand that one is standing on someone else's neck? Not pick up that one is exploiting another person? Not know? Privileged people not understand the realities?

The problem is not knowledge. The problem is kindness.

No comments:

Post a Comment